Resolved by my web host:
I found that your application was not loading because it was trying to use a functionality of a module not loaded by default in the PHP 7.4 stack:
[11-May-2020 10:59:03 America/Chicago] PHP Fatal error: Uncaught Error: Call to undefined function mb_internal_encoding() in /public_html/core/init.php:21
I loaded the module but the application still rendered the same error page but it no longer produced any error logs.
I changed the PHP version to PHP 7.3 and the website started loading. It seems there is a part of your application incompatible with PHP 7.4. It is probably an extension, plugin, or a custom theme you might be using.
At this point I don't recommend changing the PHP version to 7.4, you should keep it at 7.3.